Movie vs your imagination

When we were reading books we all had some imagined characters, the way they speak and look. Was is very different from the movie characters? Which ones you loved the best in the movie than in your imagination?

Again I will start with Bella. I like Bella more in my imagination cause in the movie she was too boring. Like all the same emotions all the time. In my imagination she smiled more and she was much sweeter with Edward than in the movie. Ok, in the movie they didn't have so much chances to be together as the movie wasn't based something more than relationships to make it interesting. But still my imagined Bella was more relaxed,

As for Edward... I really can't choose. I was thinking about that many times. My Edward was more sweeter, more naive (if we talk just about Twilight book as we haven't seen other saga's movie ). Rob's Edward was more angry with more attitude which I think made character more interesting than I was imagined him to be. I loved Edward in the book but I found him more interesting in the movie than in my head.

It's hard to tell about Jacob cause he was so less in Twilight. I liked my imagined Jake but I also accepted Taylor's Jacob. I was imagined him little bit younger, much, much naive. i think Taylor did a great job, so I also can't choose if I like better my Jacob or Taylor's. They are both acceptable.

I also wanna point out Charlie. This will be different. I was imagined him older, fat and with gray hair I really loved Burk's Charlie. He's so good! I loved those mustaches! Now every time I read the books I imagine him like Burke played him

Ok well lets get my opinion out there...

I liked the way it was brought to life on screen. But some of the characters in my imagination were alot different to the actors who played them in the film.

Lets start with Bella, she looked fairly similar there are some differences, like in my head Bella was prettier, but they do ugly Kristen Stewart up for the film, as she does look better normally then as Bella. But she was pretty similar, although more Emily Browning pretty, and a big bigger as well, because Krsiten just looks too skinny.

Ok Edward...Well when i was reading, Edward was HOT! He wasnt anything like Robert Pattinson. So it is clear that i liked my imagination Edward better then Robert as Edward. Dont get me wrong, Rob did an excellent job, but when i pictured Edward he was more, i guess, emo looking. And his hair was longer. Oh and when i was reading i pictured Edward's voice to be soft and velvety like HIM lead singer Ville Vale, only he didnt have the heavy accent Ville has.

Jacob...Well to be honest, Taylor is spot on to how i pictured Jake. I couldnt have asked for a better person to play Jacob. Even now seeing Taylor get bigger he is looking how i pictured Jacob. I mean, when i was reading i didnt picture Taylor specifically, but he was very, very, very similar. I loved Taylor and Jacob. So it was a match made in heaven for me.

Oh and you mentioned Charlie...LOL! Well i loved Burkes character, i thought he looked like a cop, either that or an 80's porn star with that moustache, i cant decide, but i never really had a concrete image of Charlie. He changed all the time.

Pretty_Twisted wrote: i thought he looked like a cop, either that or an 80's porn star with that moustache, i cant decide,

what?? porn star?? hahaha eewww, no, I wouldn't like that kind of porn star

And as for Bella's visual face or whatever. Bella in the movie pretty much looked like in my imagination. Make up artist did I good job lol

Hahaha yeah, some old school 80's porn stars had the moustache thing going on, and that was my first thought when i seen him! LOL!

In my case they were all pretty similar.

When I first saw Kristen I was like: WTH? But then with all the make up and transformation it was like: crap she came out of my imagination. She was exactly as I imagine Bella.

When I heard about rob being Edward: "HALE YES!!!" I loved him in HP4 and not knowing who he was I had him in my mind like Edward since like forever, then he gets all the make up and stuff, and BANG Edward Cullen of my mind!!!

Jacob as Taylor. Well he was my biggest dissapointment (Sorry Ten!) He wasnt my Jacob (waaa so Bella-ish ) I thought he was toooooo handsome and pretty for being Jacob. My Jacob was more like a kid in twilight, childlike. But he already was looking big!!. Now in New Moon I love him, 'cause he looks like HUGE and manly xD

Burke as Charlie. He reminds me SOOOO much to my own dad and its perfect. Just perfect, he came out from my mind too xDD

I want to add Alice, Alice was exactly as I imagine her and all the Cullens were as I imagine them except for Carlisle and Rosalie... Carlisle was waaaaaay to blond O.O and Rosalie was sooo not blond xDDD But I loved them in the movie anyways. All what I'm saying is the first impression xD I love them all now jeje

well i read the books after i watched the movie, so its hard for me...but i think all of the actors are spot on, i think they did an excellent job with casting...i think KS is perfect for Bella, she just needs a little work and prolly some more research into the books and character, Rob is perfect, exactly how i picture Edward by the way he is described physically, Billy is perfect for Charlie...and Tay is PERFECT for Jake, i dont know...i like everyone hahahah